Earl of Sandwich’s The Full Montagu

We’re continuing our 2013 Eat Each Sandwich Challenge that Nora & Nick of Extra WDW Magic thought up (#2013eateachsandwich)! Today, we’re having The Full Montagu, comprised of roasted beef, turkey, Swiss, sharp cheddar, lettuce, tomato & mustard sauce.


Normally Matt’s the one to go for Roast Beef Sandwiches, but I have to admit this one appealed more to me than him. I was interested by the addition of the turkey, two cheese, and mustard sauce. The mustard sauce, much like horseradish, is a deterrent for him.


On first look, there is a decent filling-to-bread ratio. The roast beef was nicely rare, but there were a few fatty bits I found. There was just enough mustard sauce to keep each bite interesting without being overpowering.


The roast beef was the prominent flavor, and the turkey became somewhat lost in the shuffle. The cheese was a bit of a background note as well, but some of their subtle flavors were noticeable.


While the turkey and cheeses may have been a bit quiet in this sandwich, I liked the overall flavors and addition of lettuce and tomatoes compared to The Original 1762. The mustard sauce added a touch of kick as opposed to the subtle sweetness of the horseradish sauce. It would definitely be a contender if I was in the mood for a roast beef sandwich at Earl’s again!

Challenge Checklist

Limited Time Only: BBQ Pork Sandwich
Limited Time Only: Cuban Sandwich
Limited Time Only: Chicken Pesto Pomodoro

The Original 1762
The Earl’s Club
All American
The Full Montagu
Tuna Melt
Chipotle Chicken Avocado (former Limited Time Only offering)*
Hawaiian BBQ
Ham ‘n’ Swiss
Holiday Turkey (former Limited Time Only offering)*
Caribbean Jerk Chicken
Best BLT*
Any other “Limited Time Only” offerings throughout the year*


Egg ‘N’ Cheddar
Bacon, Egg ‘N’ Cheddar*
Ham, Egg ‘N’ Cheddar
Ham ‘N’ Swiss
Breakfast BLT*


Pizza Sandwich
Grilled Cheese
Turkey ‘N’ Swiss

*Past Reviews

Chipotle Chicken Avocado
Holiday Turkey
Limited Time Only: French Dip
Best BLT
Breakfast Bacon, Egg ‘n’ Cheddar
Breakfast BLT


7 responses to “Earl of Sandwich’s The Full Montagu

  1. Its sad this doesnt have a love button. We always visit the Earl for each trip. Never disappoints us. This sandwich is the best!

  2. Their sandwiches are delicious, aren’t they? 🙂

  3. Seriously LOVE them. Even better they are included on the dining plan now

  4. Nick isn’t a huge fan of roast beef… However, I really liked this one and the Original 1762!

  5. The challenge is definitely making me branch out! 😀

  6. Well, that’s a good thing! I still haven’t had the Caprese & I don’t think that tomorrow morning is going to be the day for it 🙂

  7. That’s a good-looking sandwich, despite the mustard sauce. It’s so funny that as I read more about your and Matt’s likes and dislikes, I find myself drawing more and more comparisons between your tastes and ours. You and Danny have really similar taste, and I suspect that Matt and I do too. His aversions to mushrooms, horseradish and mustard are quirks that I share.